FRUITFUL COOPERATION
PART VI
Period 1860-1881
From its earliest beginnings, the citizens of Russia demonstrated humanity and generosity towards victims of war and armed conflict, whether military or civilian.
Nikolay Pirogov, humanist
and recognition of his contribution
Nikolay Pirogov first became involved in military surgery in 1847 during the Caucasian War due to a long-lasting Russian invasion (1817-1864) of this region. Emperor Nicholas I sent Pirogov to the warzone to demonstrate the use of the new ether technique on the battlefield Nikolay and his colleagues treated Russian soldiers, Caucasian rebels and prisoners with equal attention. In 1848 he was awarded with the Order of St.Anne 2nd class.Because of “…his pioneering work in military medicine and surgery and his concern for the amelioration of the condition of the wounded and sick in armies in the field..”Pirogov was named “…a forerunner in the struggle for humanitarian rules that was to result in the signature of the First Geneva Convention and the founding of a Red Cross Society in Russia…” This was seven years before the Crimean War, and seventeen years before the Convention of Geneva.
Crimean War (1853 – 1856)
The Crimean War played a pivotal role in the development of humanitarian aid to the victims of warfare. The surgeon Nikolay I. Pirogov and the Grand Duchess Elena Pavlovna contributed mainly to this idea. She married Grand Duke Mikhail Pavlovich Romanov, the youngest son of Emperor Paul I and Empress Maria Fyodrovna, in 1823. As sister-in-law of Emperor Nicholas I, she had easy access to him and the highest circles of the Russian and European Society. Nikolay Pirogov first met Elena Pavlovna in 1848 when returning to Saint Petersburg from the Caucasian War. She invited him to the Mikhailovsky Palace in the centre of Saint Petersburg to learn more about the conflict and his involvement. A long-lasting friendship developed. Soon after the start of the Crimean War, reports reached Saint Petersburg of the untold numbers of wounded waiting in the open air, untreated and covered in blood-soaked greatcoats. Pirogov remembered his visit to Paris in 1837, where he observed how women were involved in care in the hospitals. This observation inspired him to develop a professional role for women in health care.

Portrait of Grand Duchess Elena Pavlovna
oil on canvas, artist Natalia Evgenievna Romanova, copy from the original by Joseph-Désiré Court (1797-1865), 1842, Russia, Saint Petersburg 2013. Photographer - M.K. Lagotsky. ID GMZ Peterhof: VU 30365.
© The Peterhof State Museum-Reserve, 2021

Nurses of Holy Cross Community.

© From the collection of the Military Medical Museum, St. Petersburg

At a meeting early in October 1854, Pirogov and Elena Pavlovna discussed helping the army in Sevastopol. Pirogov blamed many unnecessary deaths and complications on the chaotic accumulation of the wounded at the dressing stations. He wanted to introduce immediate triage of the wounded, but this would require considerable paramedical personnel close to the line of action. During their conversation, both considered that women could play an essential and proper role in hospital management. The Grand Duchess told Pirogov of her plan to establish the Holy Cross Community of Nurses. Pirogov immediately gave his wholehearted endorsement and saw a role for these women in the military hospitals. Emperor Nicholas I granted his consent to their plans and appointed Pirogov as the overall head of the army medical services.

In the autumn of 1854, Elena Pavlovna appealed to Russian women to train as nurses. Soon volunteers began to arrive at the Mikhailovsky Palace. They represented all sections of Society. Most were well educated and included the wives, widows or daughters of the nobility, landowners or military officers. However, there were also nuns from nursing orders and women from the poorer classes with limited education. The Grand Duchess paid expenses, but the work was unpaid; the volunteers were motivated by a sense of patriotism and self-sacrifice.The volunteers committed themselves to practice charity, kindness and to obey their superiors. They were not permitted to accept payment or gifts from the patients. These precautions were considered necessary because they would be working among thousands of men. The volunteers underwent a short (few weeks) intensive training at the St. Petersburg Imperial Medico-Surgical Academy and other hospitalsbefore being sent to the Crimea, enabling them to lend support to surgeons working at the battlefront. They even attended operations carried out by well-known doctors, formers pupils of Pirogov.

The Grand Duchess turned her Mikhailovsky Palace into a military medical back office. The Palace became a collecting point for the materials and medicines to be shipped to Crimea. It received gifts such as drugs, bandages and linens, and many cash donations for the war effort. The Grand Duchess' ladies-in-waiting even took on duties as seamstresses and, together with volunteers, made uniforms for the nurses. The availability of charitable funds stimulated the formation of several other nursing communities.
Pirogov as the senior medical authority

Pirogov at the main dressing station in 1855, oil on canvas, artist M.P. Trufanof, 1969. КП ОФ 60743.

© From the collection of the Military Medical Museum, St. Petersburg

Because of a constant flow of nurses, Pirogov finally had sufficient female staff. In March 1855, Pirogov took upon himself the overall management of all first-aid posts and hospitals. Because of the complex workload, he decided to form the nursing staff into specialised groups. He divided them into bandage masters helping surgeons, pharmacy assistants preparing drugs and supervising their distribution, housekeepers taking care of clean linen and the sick, and overseeing the doctors and the administrative staff. Pirogov's confidence in the nurses allowed them to show their full potential. He was firm in his praise for them. He wrote:
“…The women bore superhuman strain without a murmur, with the greatest selflessness and resignation. Their conduct towards the surgeons and their assistants was exemplary; their treatment of the patients was of the kindest, and all their activities cannot be qualified other than noble…”
To deal with the massive influx of injured, Pirogov adopted and modified the use of triage earlier used by the French military surgeon Dominique-Jean Larrey to manage mass casualties. Pirogov divided the medical facilities into three sections: dressing stations right at the front, a flying brigade, and emergency field hospitals some distance behind the front. In the spring of 1855, when the fighting intensified, the management changes introduced by Pirogov proved their worth. The personnel now knew how to perform triage with an improved outcome for the patients with fewer severe casualties. They also were less exhausted, with less disease and improved job satisfaction.
The escalating violence made it necessary to evacuate the wounded and transfer them to the building of the Noble Assembly in Sevastopol, the central dressing station.
The ballroom was filled with beds and tables for bandages, and the billiard room was converted into an operating room, whose floor soon became covered in blood. In the dance hall, hundreds of amputees were nursed and in the great hall, the groans of the wounded were heard instead of dance music. One day a bomb blew a corner of the room away, where nurse Ekatarina M. Bakunin assisted in the surgery. Fortunately, she and the surgical team stayed unharmed. Other nurses assisted in minor surgeries, monitored the medicines, the pharmacy stock and kept an account of the personal belongings and money of the soldiers given to them for safekeeping.

Portrait Ekaterina Mikhailovna Bakunina.
© From the collection of the Military Medical Museum, St. Petersburg
On 23 May 1855, Pirogov returned to St. Petersburg for six weeks. He wanted to "…contribute something to change the military-medical affairs in Sevastopol for the better…" He was also exhausted and wanted to satisfy his family about his health. During his return journey to the Crimea, Pirogov saw the poor conditions of the transport of the wounded. Back in Crimea, he created departments responsible for transportation staffed by nurses. Peace negotiations to end the hostilities began in September 1855, and on 18 March 1856, the warring parties signed a peace treaty in Paris.

Portrait Nikolay Pirogov during the 50's in Crimean War
© From the collection of the SM Kirov Military Medical Academy, St. Petersburg
Comparition of the Nursing care on the Russian side during the Crimean War

Florence Nightingale's statements concerning Russian nurses and Nikolay Pirogov during the Crimean War.

In: Lynn Mcdonald, editor, Florence Nightingale on Wars and the War Office, Volume 15 of the collected works of Florence Nightingale, Canada, Wilfrid University Press

The French, Sicilians and the British also used women as nurses. Under pressure from the media and public, nurse Florence Nightingale (1820-1910) was asked to go to the Crimea to organise humanitarian aid to the wounded. Under the British military doctors, Nightingale and her small group of nurses enjoyed little authority. Florence Nightingale recognised the quality of the care for the wounded by the Russian aid in the Crimea. In her Subsidiary Notes as to the Introduction of Female Nursing into Military Hospitals in Peace and War published in 1858, she wrote '…It remains to mention the Russian system, which, as regards the organisation of the duties of the "sisters" appeared to me by far the best I have known...'. In the House of Commons, two army officers reported that Russian nurses had only insignificant duties in the hospitals on the battlefield. Nightingale corrected them and stated that '…the Russian system seems to be the only perfectly organised system of female attendants in military hospitals, that was developed in the Crimean War...'.She explained that the nurses were in charge of all that related to the patient's bedside care. They received orders from the medical officer, attended him in his rounds, conferred with him afterwards and communicated with the feldshers or nurses. Nightingale stated that the Russian organisation appeared to be the nearest approach to good organisation she had ever encountered.

Medal "For the Defense of Sevastopol", 1855.

© From the collection of the Military Medical Museum, St. Petersburg

After the Crimean war, the nurses received the social recognition they deserved, and more nursing Communities were founded. Their actions in the Crimea and the subsequent public recognition went a considerable way to establishing public acceptance of nursing and, more generally, the role of women in Russian Society. The Holy Cross Community of Nurses are regarded as the model for the Russian Red Cross nursing societies.
The emergence of a network of doctors of the military medical services
The Crimean War (1853-1857) counted many deaths and injured on both sides.
The suffering Pirogov witnessed during the Crimean War profoundly influenced his outlook on life. His way of thinking changed more toward humanitarian goals and education. He devoted his latter days to advancing the cause of medical education in Russia and actively reported and consulted on European regional conflicts for the International Red Cross.

Nikolay Pirogov made a plea for an international treaty to guarantee the safety of volunteers who provided aid to war victims on the battlefield, regardless of rank or nationality. Later, others would make similar pleas.
In the Sonderbund War, ninety-three deaths and 510 wounded were counted. Guillaume-Henri Dufour was supreme commander of the Swiss army with the highest rank as the General in wartime. He had first served in the French military from 1811 till 1817 to help to defend the French Empire. Where he since 1814 was added to the general staff. In 1859 during the Austria-Sardinia War, during which the battle of Solférino took place, Dufour was appointed the supreme commander of the Swiss army again. The battle of Solférino (1859) was the decisive battle in the Second Italian War of Independence. It was the last major battle in world history where all the armies were under the personal command of their monarchs. The Swiss surgeon, Louis Appia (1818-1898), took part in the battle. With his brother George, a pastor, he wrote letters to Italian and French doctors, collected necessary materials, and Swiss friends for fund donations. There Louis Appia met with the Swiss army general Guillaume Henri Dufour and with the head of the French military medical service, Hyppolite Larrey (son of Dominique Larrey), and Henry Dunant, a Swiss humanist and social activist. Also, another Swiss surgeon, Théodore Maunoir, a friend of Appia, and the Italian General and nationalist, Giuseppe Garibaldi, participated in this battle for freedom. Pirogov was in one or another way in contact with all mentioned persons. Although there is still no proof, it may be assumed that Pirogov, while he stayed in the German city Heidelberg in 1862-1866, had met Dunant.
Jean Henri (Henry) Dunant, a Swiss businessman, writer and social activist, arrived in Solferino on 24 June 1859.His arrival coincided with the final stages of the battle allowing for its awful aftermath. He was horrified and greatly moved by the terrible suffering of the wounded soldiers left on the battlefield and the near-total lack of medical attention and basic care. Only three years after the battle, he could bring himself to write his book in French Un souvenir de Solférino, published in 1862. Dunant also called for international treaties to guarantee the neutrality and protection of those involved in armed conflicts. In his book, Dunant acknowledged the work of Elena Pavlovna and Florence Nightingale during the Crimean War. About the Russian nurses who worked at the Crimean battlefront, Dunant wrote '…where they earned the blessing of thousands of Russian soldiers…'

Portrait Henry Dunant in the 50s
Swiss philanthropist and co-founder of the Internationmal Committee of the Red Cross. In public Domain
Front cover book Un souvenir de Solférino.
Private collection, with permission
Politically influential people took up the plea for an international treaty

Portrait Charlotte of Württemberg, Grand Duchess Elena Pavlovna Romanova in the 50s
oil on canvas, artist Christina Robertson (1796-1854). In public domain



Henry Dunant's heart-rending account of the terrible aftermath of the battle of Solférinowas translated into many different languages. It was sent to leading political, military figures and other influential individuals in Europe, including Elena Pavlovna.
He also visited many of them and had a personal meeting with the Grand Duchess Elena Pavlovna in August 1863 at Ouchy on the shores of Lake Geneva (Lake Leman), Switzerland.She promised him to interest her nephew, Emperor Alexander II, and her other relatives, including her sister-in-law Queen Anna Pavlovna of Orange; and her niece Olga Nikolaeva Romanova, the later Queen of Württemberg. The house of Romanov was in first, or second-line related to many Kingdoms and Duchies in Europe, and their commitments accelerated the process. The Kingdom of the Netherlands was among the first to follow the obligations

Portrait of Alexander II
oil on canvas, artist Ivan N. Kramskoy (1837-1887) Russian School, Russia, 1860-1870. Photographer - V.S. Korolev. ID GMZ Peterhof: GMZ Pf KP 56239 PDMP 1403-zh.
© The Peterhof State Museum-Reserve, 2021
The establishment of the Committee of the International Red Cross
The work of Dunant is considered a decisive factor leading to the foundation of the International Red Cross (ICRC). A five-person committee chaired by Gustave Moynier and Dunant, one of the critical members, was formed to investigate the possibility of implementing an organisation of care for the wounded on the battlefield. Their first meeting on 17 February 1863 is now considered the founding date of the International Committee of the Red Cross. In October 1863 the Committee of Five organised an international conference in Geneva (the first Geneva Convention) which effectively marked the launch of the Red Cross movement. During the meeting, the delegates recognised that the volunteers could endanger their lives in battle zones unless they could be readily identified as non-combatants. Accordingly, they decided that volunteers should wear an band around the arm with a distinctive identifying emblem. The emblem chosen was a red cross on a white background,
The development of the Russian Red Cross
In Russia, the idea of a voluntary committee along the lines of the Conference of Geneva gained momentum. The first meeting of the Russian Red Cross was organised on 14 December 1866. The main office was in Saint Petersburg. On 15 December, Empress Maria Aleksandrovna accepted the patronage of the Society. Nikolay Pirogov was 17 February 1867 appointed Privy Councilor to the Russian Red Cross and the Empress. In the minutes, Nikolay Pirogov is mentioned as one of the original founders of the Society. On 30 April 1867, the statute was finally approved by the members.
Pirogov as an Inspector-General for the Red Cross
Following on from the Berlin Conference in April 1869, the Russian Red Cross decided to send Nikolay Pirogov as the authorised representative to the Franco-German War in Alsace and Lorraine. He noted that one of the most important but challenging tasks was organising aid posts for the victims. He recommended establishing as many ambulatory mobile hospitals as possible, like the hospital barracks used during the Crimean War. Several forces adapted the Russian system of barracks and mobile military hospital tents.

Portrait Nikolay Pirogov in the 70s
© From the collection of the Military Medical Museum, St. Petersburg

Portrait of Grand Duchess Elena Pavlovna
paper, cardboard photography, watercolor, Photographer Joseph Albert (1825-1886), Germany, Munich, the 1870s. ID GMZ Peterhof: GMZ Pf KP 80704 ODMP 128-ik.
© The Peterhof State Museum-Reserve, 2021
On 13 September 1870, Nikolay Pirogov left for the war zone in Alsace and Lorraine as official Inspector-General of the Russian Red Cross of the Russian Ministry of Internal Affairs and on behalf of the Association for the Care of Sick and Wounded Soldiers.
In a personal meeting, Tsarina Maria Aleksandrovna asked Pirogov to report to her as she wished to be kept informed about the impact of private support on military health care facilities. The Tsarina and Grand Duchess Elena Pavlovna provided Pirogov and his companion with the necessary documents, letters and certificates of legitimacy, which would allow foreigners access to facilities at the battlefield.
In five weeks, Pirogov visited up to seventy military hospitals in France and Germany. He recorded his findings and conclusions in a Russian report to the Russian Red Cross (Report on the visit to the military - sanitary facilities in Germany, Lorraine and Elsa in 1870) In his report, he emphasised the necessity of regulations and compliance, well-to-do management with attention to the supply of materials. He also gave advice and directions for nursing associations and humanitarian activities. At the annual meeting of the Committee of the Russian Red Cross on 5 December 1870, Pirogov was unanimously awarded the honorary membership.
Front page Report on the visit to the military - sanitary facilities in Germany, Lorraine and Elsa in 1870
and the Order St. Anne 1rst class, a medal as appreciation
© From the collection of the Military Medical Museum, St. Petersburg

During the Russo-Turkish War 1877-1878, Nikolay Pirogov, now 67-year-old, travelled again on request of the Red Cross community to the war zone. He visited dressing stations and hospitals in Romania and Bulgaria to investigate the procedures, the care, the evacuation and the staff circumstances. He also instructed the doctors on how to manage patients with burns. He noted with satisfaction that the organisation and the treatment of wounded soldiers reflected what he had taught them. The Russo-Turkish (Balkan) war accelerated the development of the Russian Red Cross. The general recognition of the Sisters of Mercy was confirmed with Pirogov's verdict: '…Every doctor who works with Merciful Sisters must bow to their activity. The Merciful Sister is an indispensable aid to the doctor, especially to the surgeon. A doctor who knows and loves his job will find in the Merciful Sister his tireless assistant...'
Front page The warfare, the sanitation service, and the private aid on the battlefields in Bulgaria and in the back of the operating Army 1877 – 1878, and a medal as appreciation of the Red Cross Society concerning the War 1877-1878.
© From the collection of the Military Medical Museum, St. Petersburg
Death of Pirogov
Pirog finally retired to his estate in Vishnya (now Vinnytsia) in Ukraine, he started to write his biography Questions of Life. Diary of an old physician, written exclusively for myself, but not without a second thought, that may be somewhere somebody will read it also. He was unable to finish the diary, because his illness overtook him. He had previously diagnosed cancer himself, and recorded this in a note. On November 23, 1881, he died of tongue cancer caused by smoking a pipe. Pirogov's body was preserved by the surgeon and anatomist David Ilyich Vyvodstev, who used an embalming technique Pirogov had developed. The body of Pirogov still rests in a glass-lid coffin in a specially designed mausoleum in Pirogov's former estate, which is now a museum dedicated to his life and works.

Front cover of Pirogov's diary
© From the collection of the Military Medical Museum, St. Petersburg

Pirogov’s handwritten diagnosis of cancer and his pipe

© From the collection of the Military Medical Museum, St. Petersburg

Recognition of the role of Nikolay Pirogov
Others valued Nikolay Pirogov's heritage. His contribution to improving the plight of the casaulties of war was recognised by the Belgian Red Cross. In 1898 Frédéric A. Ferrière (1848-1924), deputy to the Grand Council and vice-president of the International Committee of the Red Cross and cousin of Louis Appia, wrote in the Bulletin International des Sociétés de la Croix-Rouge, that '…in 1854 the Grand Duchess Helene Pavlovna sent a detachment of Sisters of Mercy to the Crimean War, led by the famous surgeon Pirogov for the many wounded of all nationalities, who had fallen under the walls of Sevastopol….' He also stated in the same journal'…that the idea of the Red Cross society has its cradle in Russia. That's where it was realised for the first time...'

Charter of the Belgian Red Cross for his dedication, contribution and work

© From the collection of the Military Medical Museum, St. Petersburg

In August 1897the XII International Medical Congress took place in Moscow and other cities in Imperial Russi. Approximately 10 000 physicians from all over the world attended the congress. Nikolay Ivanovich Pirogov was posthumously honored by his medical colleagues with a monument. In the presence of many of these colleagues, on the eve of 3 August 1897, with the permission of Emperor Nicholas II, a memorial was unveiled in front of the entrance to the clinic of the medical faculty of the Moscow University.

Statue of Nikolay Pirogov in the SM Kirov Military Medical Academy in Saint Petersburg

© The Military Medical Academy named SM Kirov

Made on
Tilda